Working Thesis:
"Examining how Shylock has been adapted and appropriated by various cultures provides vital insights into the cultures themselves."
Social
Graph
- Jonelle: my stepmom. She was an English major in college, and loves to hear me talk about my occasionally out-there ideas. She will be a good person to bounce my paper off of.
Shylock, the (not) Jew, from the online video game Maobingi. Source. |
- Stephanie: an online friend of mine. She was the one that suggested I take a look at the Oregon Shakespeare Festival's production of Merchant of Venice, and mentioned some specific production choices. Given her interest in the topic, I think she could be an excellent resource.
- Nyssa: from class. Nyssa and I have been interested in each other's projects almost since the beginning. Since we're classmates, I can get feedback about how well I'm fulfilling the requirements for the project.
- Anthony Heald Interviews: Anthony Heald portrayed Shylock in a 2010 production, and offered a different way to interpret the character. He gave a series of interviews on the subject, found on YouTube (the first of which is linked to in the title). I don't know if it will work super well with my topic (which has shifted since I found these videos) but they're worth a look.
- Maobingi: while doing some random searches on the internet, I found that a Korean video game called Maobingi had incorporated the Merchant of Venice into one of its main storylines. Interestingly, Shylock's identity as a Jew is not mentioned in the game; this is likely because a) this aspect of his culture might not resonate with Koreans as much as it would with British or Americans, or b) Maobingi's probably-less-sophisticated audience would probably take it the wrong way. It's possible that reaching/performing these quests might be a little too big of a time commitment for me, so I'm going to see if I can access this content in another way: interviews or youtube videos, for example. I'm hoping I can use this as an example of an adaptation, and talk about how they portray Shylock.
- Canadian Adaptations of Shakespeare Project: Another potential resource for productions I can use is the Canadian Adaptations of Shakespeare Project website. They have several adaptations of Merchant of Venice listed, most notably "The Merchant ofVenice in Auschwitz." There didn't appear to be a whole lot of information on this particular production, but, if nothing else, I can look for more information elsewhere.
Social Networks
- Good Reads: when doing research, I found casual mentions of unusual productions to be very helpful. I spent some time looking for forums where people were discussing The Merchant of Venice so I could ask what people had seen, and the best site I was able to find was Good Reads. Within the next few days, I plan on posting on a couple listings of Merchant, asking people which plays they've seen.
- Dramaturg's Network: I found a discussion board called Dramaturg's Network, a forum designed specifically for dramaturgs (i.e. those that make decisions about how to adapt a play). I hope to be able to talk to them about the kinds of decisions they make, why they make them, and what effect they have; unfortunately, the only post I, as a non-member, could see was dated from 2011. I'm hoping there will be more recent posts available after they let me in.
- Production Directors: this might not count as a "network," but will definitely fall under the "Expert" category. I plan on emailing the directors of different productions (including BYU's children's production from last year) and asking them similar questions to those posed above. I'm hoping I can get some concrete feedback about their choices and how they changed the themes of the play.
Traditional Scholarship
I have
several sources, but for the sake of brevity I'll only post a few. Is that
okay, Professor Burton?
Bonnell, Andrew G. "Shylock and
Othello under the Nazis." German
Life and Letters 63.2 (2010): 166-178.
A
paper about how The Merchant of Venice was performed and adapted in the Third
Reich. A good, if a little extreme, example of how adaptations reflect the
culture.
Klein, Elizabeth & Shapiro,
Michael. "Shylock as crypto-Jew: a new Mexican adaptation of The Merchant of Venice." World-Wide Shakespeares: Local
appropriations in film and performance. New York: Routledge, 2005. 31-39.
This
article describes an adaptation of The
Merchant of Venice from New Mexico, called The Merchant of Santa Fe. In this adaptation, Shylock is turned
into an archetype from local colonialist history; this interplay between the
original text and local culture is exactly what I want to talk about.
This Scott, Michael? Picture taken from Wikipedia. |
Scott, Michael. "Demythologizing
Shlylock: Arnold Wesker, The Merchant;
Charles Marowitz, Variations on The
Merchant of Venice." Shakespeare
and the Modern Dramatist. New York: St. Martin's Press, 1989.
An
article discussing two rewrites of the play from the 1960s. This article
provides a look at modern adaptations, which would provide a good counterpoint
to my other, mostly historical examples.
Yes, for the sake of brevity, don't post more than a few sources.
ReplyDeleteFascinating how you found a video game that adapted Merchant of Venice into one of its storylines. Are you going to play it?
I started, but it took me like, an hour to get through the tutorial levels, and I don't know how much longer it'll take me to get to the Shakespeare quests. I'm gonna ask around, though...
ReplyDeleteI'm interested to hear a little more about the Merchant of Santa Fe. How exactly did they portray Shylock? Do you have specific examples you could post about?
ReplyDeleteDavid--I got your email about Maobingi--super cool idea! It would help me out if you noticed any points where the game version helped bring out the themes of the play for you in new ways, or how you understood characters in a different light as you played. Anything like that. I'm excited to hear about it!
ReplyDeleteGood point, Paul. If there are going to be video game adaptations, they should somehow bring you to core themes. I don't know if they are vehicles for doing much with characterization besides playing off of stereotypes, however. Interesting question.
ReplyDelete