Showing posts with label blindness. Show all posts
Showing posts with label blindness. Show all posts

Saturday, April 13, 2013

Nyssa Silvester: "I'd Say I Had Eyes Again": Redeeming Shakespeare's Gloucester for the Blind

In the recent rise of disability studies, scholars like Georgina Kleege have drawn attention to the lack of role models for the blind in classic literature. Instead, literature tends to perpetuate harmful stereotypes of blindness, including blindness accompanied by compensatory powers and blindness as punishment for sin. Shakespeare's King Lear would seem to fall into these stereotypical traps in its treatment of Gloucester during the Dover Cliff scene, where his son Edgar supposedly fools him into thinking he's jumped off a towering cliff. Based on textual evidence, though, we can read Gloucester as collaborating with Edgar in constructing this scene for the audience. Therefore, Gloucester exhibits agency and hope in crafting his renewal, and he can serve as a start for blind role models in classic literature.

Paper found here.

Thursday, April 11, 2013

The Proto-Final Draft

Okay, all. After grueling hours of figuring out what I was trying to say, I think I have my draft down pretty well. I think there are some things I want to tweak in my thesis so that it's a little more cohesive, but I'm going to call that good for tonight. Let me know if you have any comments!

Wednesday, April 10, 2013

A New Paragraph: Traditional Readings of Sight in King Lear

When I met with Dr. Burton, he suggested that my paper's argument would be stronger if I established more of a counterargument in the traditional readings of King Lear. Here is a paragraph detailing the usual way blindness is read in the play and the problems it brings up for blind studies. The next paragraph I'm going to be putting together is one that takes seriously the unity that might be disturbed in the play with my rereading. I'll take the play more seriously and try to find a new way to establish Shakespeare's parallels if I'm saying that Gloucester isn't be tricked by Edgar the way he's tricked by Edmund.

So anyway, here's the first of the new paragraphs:

The traditional reading of Gloucester’s blindness capitalizes on blindness as a reductive literary symbol. Harold C. Goddard presents a typical reading of the blind Gloucester in his essay on King Lear. Goddard points out the theme of sight and perception throughout the play: “The scene in question [Dover Cliffs scene] . . . is centered on the eyes and eyesight of Gloucester. But consider King Lear as a whole: does not practically everything in it turn on this subject of seeing? Darkness and light; blindness and vision--visions and blindness, indeed, of every kind” (143). Goddard is assuredly right to draw attention to the sight that pervades the text--there is ample evidence and justfication to bring up these parallels--but, published in 1960, his work comes from a critical tradition that does not problematize representations of disability in literature. His writing comes on especially shaky ground by today’s standards of criticism when he says, “In this, his version of The Last Judgment, Shakespeare has demonstrated that hatred and revenge are a plucking-out of the human imagination as fatal to man’s power to find his way in the universe as Cornwall’s plucking out of Gloucester’s eyes was to the guidance of his body on earth” (170). Goddard has gone so far in his textual analysis that blindness has become merely a symbol for him, abstracted as far as the Final Judgment, with no mention of the Gloucester, the actual blind character, except to say that his lack of sight equates to a lack of guidance. Even more recent and informal looks at blindness in King Lear do not push back against the purely metaphorical meaning of blindness. Sylvia Morris, an academic Shakespeare blogger, says, “The most striking [references Shakespeare makes to eyes and sight] occur in King Lear where the physical act of seeing is a metaphor for understanding and self-awareness. Sometimes words aren’t enough, and then Shakespeare translates the metaphor into action.” Even when blindness is enacted onstage, Morris chalks this action up not to character but to an extension of metaphor. It is just these types of analyses that Georgina Kleege rebuffs in her own work as “merely another version of the old story--the blind man as instructive spectacle, useful to everyone but himself” (90). Kleege seems, in essence, to want the blind in literature to be instructive in a different way, to learn how to live without site and thus, by implication, to serve as a model for blind readers. To be able to read blind role models into classic literature, we have to suspend, at least for a moment, our sighted focus on the symbolism of blindness and explore the character presented on the page without this imposed interpretive weight.

Friday, April 5, 2013

The Progress Draft

Okay, so here's the rough draft that I have for today. It's not quite finished, but I've made a lot of progress since my last one, most notably in doing my close reading. That's where the focus of my paper is, and I would really love some feedback on how convincing my interpretations are. Thanks!

Friday, March 29, 2013

Focused Annotated Bibliography

Harold C. Goddard, Meaning of Shakespeare, vol. 2
Scholarly monograph, ebook found through library, a little over fifty years old
As can be inferred from the date on this scholarship, Goddard takes an old school approach to analyzing the blindness in King Lear. Despite the difference in approach though, I think he comes to some good conclusions that should be talked about.

Georgina Kleege, Sight Unseen

Scholarly monograph, found in physical library, between ten and fifty years old
This book has been my go-to source for literary stereotypes of the blind, and it really helped me dive into the field of disability studies. Though Kleege is legally blind, she still watches movie and takes part in visual culture, making her a valuable bridge between two worlds. Her comments are insightful if challenging, sometimes, but her book has been very helpful for reorienting my viewpoint on blindness in literature.

Kenneth Jernigan, "Is Literature Against Us?"

Speech given at National Federation of the Blind meeting (potential stakeholders), between ten and fifty years old
The article that started it all for me. Kenneth Jernigan brings this conversation about blindness in literature to a head when he claims that classic literature, including King Lear, has been doing the blind a disservice by perpetuating harmful stereotypes to mostly sighted readers. Writing that I need to address in my paper.

Sylvia Morris, "Sight and Blindness in Shakespeare"

Academic blog, very recent
Though this is much more of a traditional reading of blindness in literature, one not really informed by disability studies, it provides several interesting links to the history of sight and how it has been valued throughout the past few centuries. This could prove really interesting as a contrast to my research.


Robert B. Pierce,"'I Stumbled When I Saw: Interpreting Gloucester's Blindness in King Lear"
Academic Journal, within past ten years
Pierce takes much the same approach I do to King Lear, trying to work through the way that blindness is used in it. My work will in a way be building off his; he points to the interaction of the blind Gloucester and the mad Lear as a way of breaking away from the traditional presentation of the blind in literature, and his discussions of blind stereotypes are useful. My thesis will hopefully bring his work to a more pointed conclusion.

David Richman, "Smelling Their Way to Dover: A Blind Director's Take on Blind Gloucester"
Found through footnote in Pierce, academic journal, within past ten years
This piece is fascinating and evocative, immediately issuing a challenge to the sighted reader that the fear of blindness is restricted to the sighted. I don't agree with Richman's staging of the cliffs of Dover scene, which he wants to make as darkly humorous as possible in order to highlight the emotions the audience feels about the violent blinding of Gloucester, but I will probably be pushing back against this piece in my own work.

Hannah Thompson, "Andromaque: Audio Description in the Seventeenth Century" (or similar posts from the Blind Spot blog
Academic blog, very recent
Thompson, herself a legally blind woman, writes in this post about a French play that, like King Lear, featured extensive description of the scene, this time because people in the audience couldn't see what was happening on the small stage. It might be interesting to put this play into dialogue with the way this kind of ekphrasis is used in King Lear.

Amy Vidali, "Seeing What We Know: Disability and Theories of Metaphor"
Academic journal, within past ten years
Vidali takes a classic disability studies approach and deconstructs the metaphor we have of "seeing as knowing." She proposes ways that disability studies can deal with these deeply ingrained elements of sighted culture, and since the topic is about seeing and knowledge, this article is very pertinent to the Dover Cliffs scene, where Gloucester is supposedly fooled by the sighted Edgar.

Monday, March 25, 2013

I Was Brave Today: Expanding my Social Scholarship

Today's blog post won't be very long. I finally got up the nerve to contact two scholars on disability studies or blindness in literature, and I'm hoping that these efforts work out well. I feel like I was too nervous to do a good job introducing myself and my topic, but here are the two people I emailed. I hope they write back so I can reassure them that I'm not as silly as I may have sounded the first time around.

I wish I had thought ahead and used a fountain pen.
 But I was stuck with email.
Photo credit TMAB2003

Hannah Thompson of Blind Spot

Dr. Thompson studies post-Revolution French literature and has been keeping this blog on cultural manifestations of blindness for about a year. I emailed her this morning specifically about how she, as a legally blind woman, interprets literature that she loves in spite of the way blindness is portrayed in it. I'm really hoping to hear back from her, but I'm nervous.
I found her site through Ice Rocket, which is a way cooler tool than I thought it would be.

Julia Miele Rodas

Dr. Rodas doesn't necessarily specialize in blindness, but she does list disability studies as one of her main research interests. I mostly contacted her because she's teaching a class right now about disability in literature. I asked her if maybe she could put me in touch with some of her students who might be studying blindness, so I'm hoping that works out! It would be fun to talk with people at the same stage of research as me.
Syllabus for her class.

So, sorry this was short, but I spent most of my research this morning just mustering the courage to send those emails.

Thursday, March 21, 2013

The First Three Pages

Well, guys, it's finally coming together. And after analyzing my audiences and going through some more scholarship, I discovered just how bold my thesis needed to be to work. I was up against hundreds of years of interpretations at the expense of the blind Gloucester, so I proposed a radical new way of reading King Lear.

I think my response to Jonathan Goldberg gets a little fuzzy near the end, but you'll have to tell me what you think. Obviously, this is not a complete draft, but it was a great way for me to get the ball rolling. Bring on the feedback!

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

Audiences and Publishing Venues

And here is a stretching cat.
Photo credit play4smee
I decided to evaluate my audience in three different ways: the potential readers I could attract, the publication venues I could realistically pursue, and the publication venues that would be a stretch for me.

Potential Audiences

Well, everybody, of course! But seriously, it's been hard for me to think of specific audiences the way Kara did so beautifully. I'll write at least what I have thought about:

Blind people looking for relatable literature. Much of my paper discusses harmful blind stereotypes and ways to read King Lear so that these stereotypes are assuaged. Maybe that discussion will open up King Lear a little more to the blind looking for fair representations in literature. I feel like I may be really presumptuous in aiming for this audience, though.

Undergraduate students new to disability studies. I'm hoping that talking about disability studies in a book that so many people have read will serve as a good introduction for students stumbling across the theory as I did.

Other theorists of blindness in literature. Some scholars have posed the question of how to interpret older texts that show blindness in stereotypical ways, and I'm hoping that my paper can offer some commentary of how to start this process.

"Realistic Goals" for Publication

Since my topic isn't one that most Shakespeare blogs really focus on, it seems like I should pursue more traditional scholarly routes. That said, I did reference a Shakespeare blog in my bibliography, so maybe I could submit my paper as a response to that post. My other options include the following:

BYU's English Symposium, but I want to go far beyond this venue if at all possible. The venue seems really insulated, and that's not really what I want.

BYU's Criterion. Criterion is a respectable publication and is starting to gain some traction as a nationwide undergraduate journal for literary criticism. From what I can tell, they tend to like diverse approaches to literature, so I think I would have a decent chance of publishing with them.

Susquehanna University's Literature and Creative Writing Conference. This is a relatively new literature conference, and its typical presenter is from a college in or around Pennsylvania. I could add some diversity to their lineup through both my topic and my university.

National Undergraduate Literary Conference. Though this is a national conference, its location in Ogden makes it seem accessible to someone like me without a whole lot of conference experience. It feels like a good fit.

"Stretch Goals" for Publication

National Undergraduate Research Conference. I kind of see this as one step up from the National Undergraduate Literary Conference because it caters to students of all disciplines and is held on the East Coast instead of in Utah and therefore might have more diversity among the educational background of the students. I think my paper could appeal here because it's a topic that not a lot of people are writing about, and that would set me apart.

Columbia Journal of Literary Criticism. I break into a nervous sweat just thinking about publishing with as prestigious an institution as Columbia, but I don't think I should sell myself short. I've been putting a lot of good research and thinking into this paper, and it's a fascinating topic, so I may have a chance.

Journal of Literary and Cultural Disability Studies. This is really a stretch goal because this journal is not reserved for undergraduate publications. It would mean submitting a real abstract to be published alongside PhDs and professors. I don't know if I'm ready for this, but I might still give it a shot.

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Video Preview: King Lear and Blindness


Don't you love the pained look on my face when I talk about my ideas?

Anyway, this video helped me pick out the most salient points of my argument, the ones I need to focus on the most: the cliffs of Dover scene read as Edgar giving his father new life (not read as a comedy, in other words) and the little glimmers of hope for Gloucester's future that are in surrounding scenes. Clearly, blind studies needs to be included as a background, but I need to get back to diving into the primary text even more than I already have.

Friday, March 15, 2013

Annotated Bibliography and Semi-Official Tweethis Statement

Thanks to an illuminating, albeit brief, exchange with Rachel, I've figured out the little bit of pith that I needed for my thesis statement. Here it is.

Though Gloucester can be seen as just another stereotypical manifestation of the Oedipal view of blindness, it is really only in his blinding that we find these elements. In fact, Gloucester in his blindness is presented as a capable human being.

And now, on to the annotated bibliography, which is probably not nearly as thorough as Paul's.

Social Graph

1. My husband, Neal Silvester. He is one of the few people I can depend on to listen to me no matter what, and he offers me a fresh perspective when I get too immersed in the academia side of my research. He pulls me back to the original text no matter what, and that's a good strength to have on my team.

2. My mom and her friend Genie. See my post talking about the connections I made through Facebook. I haven't heard back from the people I messaged yet, but I plan to give them a friendly reminder today to see if they have any thoughts on the questions I asked.

3. My coworkers at the Religious Studies Center. I work with a couple of very capable English majors and other very smart people at my work, and I've already briefly introduced them to my topic. They seemed really interested in it, so it's totally possible that they could have good ideas for what to include in my paper.

New Media

This is the part I've been most struggling with. There aren't a lot of people blogging about my specific topic, but I have found some very evocative blog posts that I want to comment on.

1. "'The Power of Shakespeare in Any Medium': The American Print House for the Blind Production of Much Ado About Nothing," by Kathi E. B. Ellis. Though this post doesn't talk much about literary criticism and theory, it does mention how many members of the production used Braille scripts, and it got me thinking back to the audio versions of the play we listened to. I'm probably going to see if I can find an audio version of King Lear and see how they interpreted both the blinding of Gloucester and the cliffs of Dover scene. Although these scenes revolve around blinding and blindness, they rely a lot on the sight of the audience to understand the spectacle and the intended emotional effect.

2. "How Blindness Is Often Depicted," by Bridgit Kuenning-Pollpeter. This is a remarkable blog post that cleverly juxtaposes a depiction of the supposed horrors of blindness on Law and Order with the everyday life of a blind woman and her fiance. I highly recommend reading it to get a sense of the two depictions of blindness I'm going to be comparing in King Lear: the fear of blindness that plagues most of the world and the humanity that blind people want to be accorded.

3. "Sight and Blindness in Shakespeare," by Sylvia Morris. Though this is much more of a traditional reading of blindness in literature, one not really informed by disability studies, it provides several interesting links to the history of sight and how it has been valued throughout the past few centuries. This could prove really interesting as a contrast to my research.

Social Networks

1. There's the possibility of going to the Goodreads group that everyone else in the class has been flocking to, but I don't think it's a good fit for me and my project. Still, I'll try posting something there and seeing what happens.

2. There are a few groups on LinkedIn that are communities of the blind. I'm a little bit wary to get in contact with these groups, though, simply because I don't want to look like I'm using them as mere data points in my project. These aren't really literature groups; they're people who deal with blindness every day, and I don't know if I'll be interpreted as ungracious if I stop by.

3. Academia.edu actually has a thriving disability studies community, and its blindness community is nothing to sneeze at. There are a wealth of people I could talk to here, and I'm excited to have stumbled across this source.

Traditional Sources

1. Georgina Kleege, Sight Unseen. This book has been my go-to source for literary stereotypes of the blind, and it really helped me dive into the field of disability studies. Though Kleege is legally blind, she still watches movie and takes part in visual culture, making her a valuable bridge between two worlds. Her comments are insightful if challenging, sometimes, but her book has been very helpful for reorienting my viewpoint on blindness in literature.

2. "'I Stumbled When I Saw: Interpreting Gloucester's Blindness in King Lear," by Robert B. Pierce. Pierce takes much the same approach I do to King Lear, trying to work through the way that blindness is used in it. My work will in a way be building off his; he points to the interaction of the blind Gloucester and the mad Lear as a way of breaking away from the traditional presentation of the blind in literature, and his discussions of blind stereotypes are useful. My thesis will hopefully bring his work to a more pointed conclusion.

3. "Smelling Their Way to Dover: A Blind Director's Take on Blind Gloucester," by David Richman. This piece is fascinating and evocative, immediately issuing a challenge to the sighted reader that the fear of blindness is restricted to the sighted. I don't agree with Richman's staging of the cliffs of Dover scene, which he wants to make as darkly humorous as possible in order to highlight the emotions the audience feels about the violent blinding of Gloucester, but I will probably be pushing back against this piece in my own work.

4. "Justifying the Unjustifiable: The Dover Cliff Scene in King Lear," by Winfried Schleiner. This older article, from 1985, takes on the staging of the cliffs of Dover scene of King Lear, using Renaissance psychology and medicine to explain why the scene should be staged on a small hill and not on a flat stage. This sounds like quite a tangential point to make, but Schleiner is a defender of the Dover scene in a way that I want to be. He doesn't take it to be a farce but an act of love from son to father, and I want to include some of that dynamic in my paper.

So that's what I have right now. Time to start synthesizing ideas!

Hanging on to the Bandwagon

As for many other people posting on the blog, this week has been hectic for me, and I feel like I haven't made as much progress as I would have wanted. I have been working on my annotated bibliography, but for right now, I'm going to do a brief post on a few other aspects of this process.

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Close Reading, Part 1: Finding a Human, Blind Gloucester

I've been hesitant to actually post a class reading of King Lear because I'm so new to the study of blindness, and I've been doing the best I can to first understand the objections that blind critics have to portrayals of blindness in literature. Perhaps the criticism that I've been thinking through most comes from Georgina Kleege, a legally blind professor of literature at UC Berkeley. In her memoir, Sight Unseen, she writes of portrayals of the blind in literature:
These are the old stories of blindness. They make me weary and a little afraid. They take Oedipus at his word, and start from the assumption that blindness is both an outward sign of hidden sin and a punishment worse than death. They show no life after blindness, offer no hope to the blind, except that the condition might prove impermanent or that death might come quick. . . . And this is the whole point. If Oedipus got used to the idea of his lost sight, much less adopted new methods of getting around or recognizing people, then his blindness would be less of a punishment. He would cease to be the instructive and frightening spectacle he voluntarily made of himself. (73-74)
Right now, my thinking is that Gloucester is not an "instructive and frightening spectacle" for at least two reasons:
  1. Gloucester is not treated as a pure symbol by people in the text. Though he is certainly despondent about being blinded, he shows some hopes for living, and other people around him try to help him adapt to his new life of blindness, unlike in the case with Oedipus.
  2. Watch as I muddle through my close reading!
  3. The instructiveness of Gloucester is problematized (but certainly not solved all the way) by Edmund's fulfillment of his position. As Steve mentioned in class, Edmund the bastard kind of acts like a bastard, so it's impossible to say that Gloucester's blinding was an uncomplicated punishment for treating Edmund, well, like a bastard. 
Ultimately, though, I want to get to the scene that I love so much: the cliffs of Dover, where Edward tries to create a new life for his father through language, and a figurative death and rebirth. But I'm not quite there in my rereading, and there's a lot of depth to plumb here. So, I'll start with point 1 in this post, and probably work on the other two throughout the week as I work on developing my tweethis and annotated bibliography.

Thursday, March 7, 2013

Being Symbolically Blind in Shakespeare

This post might run a little long because a lot has happened in the development of my paper. The story, starting from two days ago:

First, I started pursuing the lead that David recommended to me: disability studies. In my last post, I mentioned that approach only because . . . well, I had heard of it, and it seemed like it could be applicable to Gloucester losing his eyes in King Lear and the subsequent cliffs of Dover scene with Edgar. I decided to look into blindness in literature from the perspective of the blind, and I got an intellectual punch in the gut.

This speech challenged entirely the way I view the symbolism of blindness in literature. In it, Kenneth Jernigan discusses—and, frankly, excoriates—the stereotypical ways blindness is treated in literature. Here in Jernigan tearing down blindness as a symbol of other blessings gained:
 CC License by M needs a docctor
The sickest of all the romantic illusions is the pious opinion that blindness is only a blessing in disguise. In "The Blind Girl of Wittenberg", by John G. Morris, a young man says to the heroine: "God has deprived you of sight but only that your heart might be illuminated with more brilliant light." Every blind girl I know would have slapped his face for such insulting drivel; but the reply of this fictional female is worse than the original remark: "Do you not think, sir," she says, "that we blind people have a world within us which is perhaps more beautiful than yours, and that we have a light within us which shines more brilliantly than your sun?"
Jernigan is also critical of the way Gloucester is portrayed in King Lear, saying that Shakespeare "makes the blinded Gloucester in 'King Lear' so thoroughly confused and helpless that he can be persuaded of anything and deceived by any trick." And at this point, even though I had been attentively and sympathetically reading the rest of the article, I revolted.

I love the cliffs of Dover scene in King Lear, and though I think there may be some dark humor in it, I hardly see it as mocking Gloucester in his blindness. Though this idea is still tentative, I think Edgar is instead trying to construct a new life for his father, who is filled with grief at the violence he has undergone. In other words, we shouldn't read this scene as literal comedy but as symbolic, renewing drama, culminating in Edgar's line "Thy life's a miracle" (Lear IV.xi).

I will be writing further posts about blindness in disability studies, but I figure this post is a good start for explaining my paper.