Causal- A close examination of the play Twelfth Night suggests the significance of the romantic pairings within the plot. They exist not to symbolize heterosexuality as the social norm, but rather to challenge gender identity and sexuality all together. Viola's character demonstrates that gender is a fluid identity and not a permanent role received at birth depending on genitalia. By doing so, Shakespeare challenges binary gender identities and the entire notion of it.
Comparison- Although gender identity is an issue where many still are unsure, Twelfth Night shows that gender is a fluid identity that is not determined by birth.
Policy- Although many argue gender is determined by birth, Shakespeare's play Twelfth Night shows gender identity should be chosen by the individual and should not by determined by genitalia.
Definition- Although it is a cultural norm to identify gender by genitalia, Shakespeare teaches in Twelfth Night that gender identity is fluid because Viola operates her gender in order to achieve a desired end, not because of her genitalia.
Evaluation- Although Shakespeare's play Twelfth Night depicts the possibilities of determining gender identity, it is inappropriate for society to accept this theme because the social norm is to determine gender by birth.
I have some really interesting readings on feminist theory that I think you would find helpful. I'll try to bring copies today, but I can also email them to you. Seriously, this is such a rich topic, and I love that you differentiated between the concepts of "sex" and "gender."
ReplyDeleteexcellent thoughts! This is such an interesting and relevant topic today, which makes it all the more interesting. You could also tie this into the historical background of men playing women's role and how that makes it an even more interesting commentary, somehow.
ReplyDelete