Title: Overcoming the Stigma: Mental Illness in Shakespeare’s Day and Ours
Thesis: Although
there is a great mental illness stigma present in today’s society,
deconstructing Shakespeare’s characters will allow us to see how ordinary
individuals develop mental illness and the necessity of getting medical attention.
Annotated Bibliography:
Arboleda-Flórez, Julio and Norman Sartorius eds. Understanding
the Stigma of Mental Illness: Theory and Interventions. Chichester: John
Wiley & Sons, 2008. Web. 30 November 2015. <http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/book/10.1002/9780470997642>
This article talks about how the stigma of mental illness
came about historically. This is going
to help me to explain how the stigma exists and prove in a way that it truly
does exist. Then from there I will be
able to jump into my thesis and how Shakespeare is related to that.
Somerville, H. Madness In Shakespearian Tragedy.
London: The Richards Press LTD., 1969. Print.
This is a book that goes through several of the tragedies
talking about how madness developed in key characters. This book is going to help me look at the
characters’ development of mental illness so that I can show how they were
normal people with many internal conflicts that would have been fine if they
would have had the necessary mental health services available to them. Ultimately teaching us that we don’t have to
be worried about a stigma to get the help we need, instead we should be worried
about not getting help.
Chan, K.K.S. and W.W.S Mak. "The Prevalence of
Stereotype Self-concurrence and Habitual Self-stigma in a Community Sample of
People with Mental Illness." European Psychiatry 28-31 March 2015:
1375. Web. 30 November 2015. <http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S092493381531066X>
This is a report of a survey that was taken which basically
says that people with mental illness put the stereotype on themselves making
the mental illness more difficult. This
goes along the lines of one of my claims with King Lear in which he dreaded
going mad and that was one of the reasons why he went mad. So it can back up that point and show how a
stigma whether self-imposed or imposed by the public can lead people to not get
the help they need and the condition can worsen.
Freidl, M., T. Lang and M. Scherer. "How psychiatric
patients perceive the public's stereotype of mental illness." Social
Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 38.5 (2003-05): 269-75. Web. 30
November 2015. <http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00127-003-0626-3#>
This journal article draws on several surveys talking about
the mental illness stigma and how it affects the public and the mentally
ill. I think it will help me not only
further establish my thesis, but it will also give my paper a so-what. The so-what being that all people are affected
by this whether mentally ill or not, and so we need to overcome this mental
illness stigma issue.
Hom, Melanie A., Ian H. Stanley and Thomas E. Joiner Jr.
"Evaluating factors and interventions that influence help-seeking and
mental health service utilization among suicidal individuals: A review of the
literature." Clinical Psychology Review 27 May 2015: 28-39. Web. 30
November 2015. <http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0272735815000768>
This talks about the factors that cause people to not take
advantage of mental health services. By
seeing all of the factors determined through several surveys it will better
support my thesis in that people don’t take advantage of the mental health
services. It also suggests that the
stigma of mental illness can be the cause to all of the other supposed causes
of not taking advantage of mental health services.
Thiher, Allen. Revels in Madness: Insanity in Medicine and
Literature. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press, 1999. Print.
This book talks about how insanity was treated in
Shakespeare’s time or in better words, how it wasn’t treated. This is going to help me in my argument by
showing that the characters in Shakespeare’s plays had tragic endings because
the help was not available. In contrast,
people do not need to be like that today because of all the help that is
available to us.
Schomerus, Georg, Herbert Matschinger and Matthias C.
Angermeyer. "Traces of Freud - The Unconscious Conflict as a Cause of
Mental Disorders in the Eyes of the General Public." Psychopathology
(2008): 173-178. Web. 23 November 2015.
This is a survey that is based off
of Freud's philosophy that mental disorders are caused by unconscious conflict.
The survey shows that it is. This is going to help me to be able to
show how the characters of King Lear, Othello, and Macbeth were normal people
with conflicts that led them to developing a mental illness. Therefore
demonstrating that there should not be a stigma against people who develop a
mental illness because anyone can. I also am going to use this to do more research on Freud's philosophy on the subject.
This sounds like a super interesting paper! Though I feel like the purpose of the paper is centered around mental illness and that Shakespeare is one way that we can understand mental illness, among other things. I feel like it might be better to have Shakespeare and an analysis of mental illness in Shakespeare rather than trying too hard to connect it to the necessity of getting medical attention and understanding stigmas around mental illness. I guess I'm just thinking it should primarily be a paper about Shakespeare, not mental illness. Thats my opinion though, and I can't really tell what your whole plan is just from this. Those are just a few thoughts!
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like a super interesting paper! Though I feel like the purpose of the paper is centered around mental illness and that Shakespeare is one way that we can understand mental illness, among other things. I feel like it might be better to have Shakespeare and an analysis of mental illness in Shakespeare rather than trying too hard to connect it to the necessity of getting medical attention and understanding stigmas around mental illness. I guess I'm just thinking it should primarily be a paper about Shakespeare, not mental illness. Thats my opinion though, and I can't really tell what your whole plan is just from this. Those are just a few thoughts!
ReplyDelete